December 10, 200718 yr Usually being the techish guy, I like to make sure things get done.... Before the little bundle of joy gets here in late spring/early summer, I am planning to get a bunch of work/updates on her car so there should (I said should) be any surprises afterward (at least for a good while) She still has the Delco in her car, which will be five years in the spring. Should I think about reaplacing it before then? It's been good so far.... If it was my car, I would just wait until it dies...... But when you have a baby in there, that is not a surprise that you want............ What do you guys think? Wait a while? Just do it?
December 10, 200718 yr I'd stick and wait a while... I replaced the Delco original battery in my Cavalier last spring and it only died because my mom left the headlights on overnight.
December 10, 200718 yr The original AC Delco battery in my Camaro lasted a little over 5 years. It died shortly after I stopped driving the car on a regular basis.
December 11, 200718 yr Author I'd stick and wait a while... I replaced the Delco original battery in my Cavalier last spring and it only died because my mom left the headlights on overnight. Your battery lasted 10 ten years? Wow!
December 11, 200718 yr a friend had to replace his in a 99 grand am just last week, cause a terminal failed.
December 14, 200718 yr The problem is the way modern batteries are designed- there is no longer a warning 'slow-down', where you get the idea the battery is no longer up-to-snuff. Instead, for what reason I have not learned, they perform like Day 1 until Day Last, when they die instantly & without warning. I drove my '94 everyday on the factory battery. One day in the summer of 2001 I drove to work without incident, but 2 hours later when I went out to drive off, it was stone dead (no- no lights or any other accessories left on- it basically has none to speak of). It's a real shortcoming, IMO. I've heard this scenario repeated by others many times- seems the average life is right close to 7 years. I would bet on 1 more year with your battery, but then I would start to think about it if you are particularly worried about getting stranded.
December 15, 200718 yr Truthfully, and not saying this as a parts guy who is here to sell a part, or throw out a company's name. 5 years is typical for most batteries. I will admit that GM and Ford tend to put the best batteries in their vehicles from the factory, because most of the batteries we sell at work are for imports and DCX products. I would go ahead and replace it if it were me. Five years is plenty long for a battery and like you said, and like balth said, they aren't going to give you a warning, they're just going to konk out on you.
December 15, 200718 yr Author Truthfully, and not saying this as a parts guy who is here to sell a part, or throw out a company's name. 5 years is typical for most batteries. I will admit that GM and Ford tend to put the best batteries in their vehicles from the factory, because most of the batteries we sell at work are for imports and DCX products. I would go ahead and replace it if it were me. Five years is plenty long for a battery and like you said, and like balth said, they aren't going to give you a warning, they're just going to konk out on you. Yeah, that sounds good..... Might even give me a chance to upgrade the battery... Diehard, Maybe? Got to keep the Wifie safe.....
December 16, 200718 yr The battery in the BMW lasted 7 years, and when it was about the die, it was slow to crank. It looked really nice, too -- shiiny iPod white. The battery in the Odyssey crapped out without warning in a parking lot at night after just 4 years. Even the power door locks wouldn't work. Wonder if it has anything to do with the capacity of the alternator, the quality of the battery, etc..
December 18, 200718 yr That was my exact experience with the battery in my '99 Odyssey except I was stranded during the day. Lasted 4 years - no warning that the battery was going bad. The dealer-installed replacement went bad a year later - no cost to me. The battery in my new '01 BMW lasted less than a year. Always wondered if it had something to do with trying to jump the Odyssey. Now wondering when the Mopar battery in my '05 Jeep will go. I'd be happy with 5 years. The battery in the BMW lasted 7 years, and when it was about the die, it was slow to crank. It looked really nice, too -- shiiny iPod white. The battery in the Odyssey crapped out without warning in a parking lot at night after just 4 years. Even the power door locks wouldn't work. Wonder if it has anything to do with the capacity of the alternator, the quality of the battery, etc..
December 18, 200718 yr The original battery in my GC lasted about 4 1/2 years and died with no warning. One afternoon, click, no start. I replaced the original with a Diehard. The Diehard in my '87 Mustang is now over 8 years old, but I start that car every two weeks, keep it on a trickle charge, and drive it maybe 500 miles a year.
December 18, 200718 yr Author The Diehard in the wagon is five years old now... Still works in the coldest weather...
December 23, 200718 yr DieHard builds a pretty good battery, so does CarQuest, AutoZone and Advance Auto, most NAPA batteries are pretty fair too. I'd shy away from Interstate batteries simply because they seem to be pretty shoddily constructed. Any of those would be a good recommendation for you.
December 24, 200718 yr Author DieHard builds a pretty good battery, so does CarQuest, AutoZone and Advance Auto, most NAPA batteries are pretty fair too. I'd shy away from Interstate batteries simply because they seem to be pretty shoddily constructed. Any of those would be a good recommendation for you. I've heard the same thing about interstate... The Neon had a NAPA....those seem to be hit or miss... I wonder who makes Autozone and Advance batteries....
December 30, 200718 yr AutoZone's batteries are made by Johnson Controls, Advance batteries are marketed by AutoCraft, but if I believe they are built by Johnson Controls also. NAPA, CarQuest and a couple of other companies are made by East Penn/DEKA, which is a good company.
January 3, 200818 yr wouldn't surprise me, there are a few DEKA-branded battery dealers here and there.
January 5, 200818 yr Author wouldn't surprise me, there are a few DEKA-branded battery dealers here and there. I haven't seem any around lately though....I might consider one-I had real good luck with the first one....
January 7, 200818 yr Author Optima Red top is very good battery, but might be overkill for your application. Well, I could add a nice sound system... :AH-HA_wink:
January 8, 200818 yr Really and truly unless you're running a killer sound system or you are subjecting your vehicle to massive vibrations and jolts from jumping it off stumps and the like, then an Optima battery is pretty much overkill for any "stock" vehicle.
January 8, 200818 yr Author Really and truly unless you're running a killer sound system or you are subjecting your vehicle to massive vibrations and jolts from jumping it off stumps and the like, then an Optima battery is pretty much overkill for any "stock" vehicle. True, and one wouldn't want to spend 130 bucks on one either...
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.