Presented without comment.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-594683847743189197

So who else has seen it?

Saw it months ago.

1st part - love it

2nd part - thought provoking

3rd part - not buying it

But I'm an atheist, liberal swine, so what do I know...

Thanks Walt.

All I will say is that it was one of the most affecting films I have ever seen.

No one else has seen it?

I'm surprised.

I have a problem with the title, in German it can mean many things but all deal with events that happen only in the past, no present or future events can be included.

I have a problem with the title, in German it can mean many things but all deal with events that happen only in the past, no present or future events can be included.

So have you seen it?

So have you seen it?

Nein habe ich nicht. Should I?

Nein habe ich nicht. Should I?

Yeah, I think it's worth experiencing.

And then thinking about for a bit.

I watched the 1st part thru, but bailed on the 2nd.

I had problems with what I saw as some inconsistancies in the 1st part- make a cohesive presentation that fires on all cylinders and you'll get an honest open-minded 'hmmm' from me. Otherwise I'm going to toss it out the window.

I watched the 1st part thru, but bailed on the 2nd.

I had problems with what I saw as some inconsistancies in the 1st part- make a cohesive presentation that fires on all cylinders and you'll get an honest open-minded 'hmmm' from me. Otherwise I'm going to toss it out the window.

Yeah, the structure is weak in that way. However, to really get a decent sense of it you need to see it all.